Bootleg Papa

''"No. I said Pizzas. Pizzazz makes me want to strangle myself." - Bootleg Papa (Episode 9)''

Bootleg Papa features the exact same text color and text to speech voice as Papa. He originates from the Bootleg Dimension, along with Bootleg Chris. He is fairly similar to the original Papa, however a big difference is is dislike for pizzazz and his liking of pizza.

He is a side character in JRmysteries, and has made an appearance in 4 episodes. In episode 12, he has contact with Papa and claims that he is the original.